Brancacci Chapel: A Renaissance Fresco Cycle in Florence
Site at a Glance
- Rating
- 4.4
- Popularity
- Medium
- Country
- Italy
- Primary era
- Medieval
- External website
- Open
- Eras represented
- Medieval, Early Modern
- Civilizations
- Grand Duchy of Tuscany, Republic of Florence
- Site type
- Religious
- Remains
- Chapel
On this page21 sections
History
The Brancacci Chapel is a late fourteenth-century family chapel in Florence, Italy, built within Santa Maria del Carmine by members of the Brancacci family and decorated in the early Renaissance with scenes from the life of Saint Peter. Located at the end of the church’s right transept, it was dedicated to Peter, the family’s patron saint, and became associated with the Carmelite order and the Catholic Archdiocese of Florence.
Brancacci foundation and early decoration
Pietro di Piuvichese Brancacci commissioned a family chapel in the Carmine church in 1367, and Antonio Brancacci began further work in 1387. The chapel is also dated to 1386 in some accounts, while its surviving fresco decoration belongs to a later generation. The original foundation therefore preceded the celebrated paintings by several decades.
After returning from a diplomatic embassy to Cairo on 15 February 1423, Felice Brancacci, a wealthy silk merchant and influential figure in Florentine politics, commissioned Masolino da Panicale, probably through his workshop, to paint scenes from the life of Saint Peter. Work began by the end of 1424, although another chronological reconstruction places its beginning around 1422 to 1424. Masolino had completed work at Empoli in November 1424 before starting the chapel’s fresco cycle.
Masolino and Masaccio
Masaccio, a pioneering Florentine painter of the early Renaissance, became Masolino’s assistant and assumed much of the work after Masolino left for Hungary on 1 September 1425 to serve as a court painter. Masolino returned in 1427, allowing the two artists to continue the cycle together. Their method was unusual in its close coordination. They worked on adjoining scenes from a single rectangular scaffold, alternating between the side and end walls so that the paintings would form a continuous visual whole rather than a set of sharply separated contributions.
The upper register, and probably part of the lunettes, was completed through this collaboration, while the lower register remained unfinished. Masaccio’s departure for Rome and death there in the summer of 1428 interrupted the project. Some reconstructions place his withdrawal as early as February 1426, but the principal interruption is generally placed in 1427 to 1428. Felice Brancacci’s will of 1432 still described the chapel as incomplete.
Political reversal and rededication
The unfinished state of the chapel was also connected with Felice Brancacci’s political downfall. He was imprisoned in Capodistria in 1435, exiled in 1436 after aligning himself with opponents of Cosimo de’ Medici, and declared a rebel in 1458. His property was confiscated, and portraits of Brancacci family members and other politically unacceptable figures were probably damaged or removed during this period.
Around 1458 to 1460, the chapel was rededicated to the Madonna del Popolo and references to the Brancacci family were stripped away. A thirteenth-century Madonna and Child, probably dating from around 1268, was installed on the altar in 1454 or after the rededication. The original fresco of the Martyrdom of Saint Peter behind the altar was probably destroyed to accommodate the new arrangement.
Filippino Lippi completes the cycle
When the Brancacci family returned to Florence in 1480, Filippino Lippi was commissioned to complete the paintings. His intervention is generally dated to about 1480 to 1485, with the year 1485 proposed in connection with a possible portrait of the young painter Francesco Granacci. Filippino adapted his palette and solemn figures to the earlier frescoes while retaining the mature chiaroscuro and sharply defined contours associated with his own period. His work completed the narrative of Saint Peter and connected the unfinished early Renaissance programme with the later Florentine Renaissance.
Later alterations and damage
The Brancacci patronage declined during the sixteenth century. In 1780, the Brancacci descendants, the French-based marquises de Brancas, formally renounced their rights to the chapel. Patronage passed to the Riccardi in 1782, and their coat of arms, showing a key, remains beside the present altar.
The frescoes were cleaned in 1565 and restored in 1670 to 1674. During the seventeenth century, the chapel received silver furnishings, a carved and gilded cornice, a marble balustrade, a new altar, and other additions. A proposed conversion from Gothic to Baroque design, planned by the Marquis Feroni and the Carmelites in 1690, was not carried out. Around 1642, palm or olive branches were painted over the nudity of Adam and Eve.
Further changes in 1746 to 1748 altered the upper part of the chapel. Masolino’s frescoes of the four Evangelists in the ribbed vault were destroyed to make room for a small dome, which Vincenzo Meucci decorated with the Madonna Giving the Scapular to Saint Simon Stock. Carlo Sacconi’s illusionistic frescoes replaced the upper lunettes, and the original Gothic mullioned window was exchanged for a larger Baroque window. Much of the upper decoration on the rear wall was consequently destroyed.
A major fire destroyed the basilica in 1771 and damaged the chapel. The frescoes largely survived, but their plaster and colours were burned, blackened, and otherwise damaged, while the wooden divisions between the paintings deteriorated. The Madonna and Child survived because it had been moved into the convent about a year earlier. The inscription Signum Salutis in Periculis, meaning a sign of salvation in dangers, was later added to the shields of the pendentives in memory of the fire.
Modern conservation and artistic importance
A conservation treatment in 1940 used a protective mixture of egg and casein and revived the colours. In 1932, Ugo Procacci discovered fragments of relatively undamaged fresco beneath two marble slabs of the eighteenth-century altar. These fragments revealed the brilliance of the colours before the eighteenth-century alterations.
Detailed investigations preceded the principal restoration of 1983 to 1990, conducted jointly by Umberto Baldini and Ornella Casazza. The work removed later obscuring material, clarified the distinction between original and later painting, and restored the cycle’s brighter colours and visual balance. It also revealed sinopie, preparatory drawings beneath or associated with frescoes, for the lost Repentance of Saint Peter, probably by Masaccio, and Saint Peter’s Mission, attributed to Masolino. Masaccio’s participation from the beginning was confirmed by the discovery of his hand in one of the semi-lunettes.
The restoration also recovered decorative fragments and two heads around the original window embrasures, as well as a painted fragment probably belonging to Masaccio’s lost Crucifixion of Saint Peter. The chapel became an important centre for the study of early Renaissance art. Masaccio’s use of perspective, unified illumination, strong chiaroscuro, psychologically individualized figures, and solidly modelled bodies influenced later generations. Giorgio Vasari called the chapel a school of the world, and Michelangelo is recorded as having studied and copied its frescoes.
The programme presents Christian history from the Fall of Adam and Eve to Saint Peter’s ministry as Christ’s heir and founder of the Roman Church. Its narrative draws on Genesis, the Gospels, the Acts of the Apostles, and the Golden Legend, a medieval collection of saints’ lives compiled by Jacobus de Voragine. Peter’s central position reflects both his place as the Brancacci patron saint and his traditional role as the first pope and founder of the Roman Church. The programme therefore also carried associations with the papacy, the Carmelite church, and the pro-papal climate of Florence during the pontificate of Martin V, pope from 1417 to 1431.
The juxtaposition of Genesis scenes with episodes from Peter’s history could suggest a parallel between God’s creation, Peter’s creation of the Church and papacy, and Martin V’s restoration of the Roman see after the Western Schism. The Tribute Money and the Distribution of Alms and Death of Ananias have also been interpreted as allusions to the Florentine catasto, the income-based tax assessment system introduced in 1427.
Remains
The chapel occupies the end of the right transept of Santa Maria del Carmine. Its interior measures approximately 6.96 metres in depth and 5.38 metres in width. The surviving decoration is organized across the side and rear walls within a common painted architectural framework. Corinthian pilasters and a dentilled cornice unite the scenes, while continuing landscapes, coherent perspective systems, and a shared direction of light connect paintings across the chapel.
Form and surviving framework
The original arrangement had three painted registers beneath a ribbed cross-vault. Painted or simulated marble panelling occupied the lower portion. Paired corner pilasters separated the altar-wall decoration from the scenes on the side walls and supported the dentilled cornice. Comparable pilasters and a cornice probably continued near the entrance arch.
The chapel’s appearance has been altered since the fifteenth century. The pointed entrance arch became semicircular, the tall Gothic bifora, or mullioned window, was replaced by a larger rectangular Baroque window, and the ribbed vault was partly replaced by a small dome. The upper lunettes were destroyed or covered. The restoration recovered pale colours around the former Gothic window, together with decorative tendrils and two male and female heads, and exposed architectural and facial details that later interventions had concealed.
Upper register
Adam and Eve
In the upper part of the right wall, Masolino painted the Temptation of Adam and Eve in a tall, narrow field within the thickness of the arch. Adam stands beside Eve as she accepts the forbidden fruit from the serpent. Soft light, a dark background, late Gothic courtly gestures, and the serpent’s idealized blond head give the scene a refined character. On the opposite upper left wall, Masaccio painted the Expulsion from the Garden of Eden. Adam covers his face in despair, Eve cries out while concealing her nudity, and an armed angel drives them from Paradise. Their massive, firmly grounded bodies and sharply modelled shadows contrast with Masolino’s more decorative treatment. The foliage once painted over their bodies was removed during the 1990 restoration.
The Tribute Money
The Tribute Money, largely attributed to Masaccio and dated to 1425, occupies the upper left wall. It was executed in thirty-two giornate, or daily sections of fresco work, and combines three moments from Matthew 17:24-27 in one landscape. Christ directs Peter to obtain a coin from a fish, Peter takes the coin at the lakeshore, and Peter pays the tax collector at the city gate.
The scene is organized around a single vanishing point behind Christ’s head. The apostles form coherent groups, while grassy mountains, trees, city walls, projecting loggias, and awnings create a consistent spatial setting. Sunlight and shadow follow one direction throughout the composition. A figure in a wine-coloured garment has been interpreted variously as Masaccio’s self-portrait or as a portrait of Felice Brancacci.
Saint Peter Preaching
On the rear wall, Masolino painted Saint Peter Preaching in eight giornate. Peter addresses a crowd whose responses vary from the attention of a veiled woman to the sleepiness of a girl, the concentration of a bearded old man, and the fear of a woman with furrowed eyes. The mountains continue visually from the Tribute Money, creating continuity between the two compositions. Several figures may represent contemporaries.
Scenes of baptism and healing
Beyond the window on the upper right wall, Masaccio painted the Baptism of the Neophytes. Peter baptizes young men in a steep-sided valley. One kneels in the river, another shivers while waiting unclothed, a third removes his clothing, and a fourth, barefoot with wet hair, buttons a blue tunic. The painting emphasizes the physical effects of water on bodies, hair, and fabric. Contrasting drapery colours produce a shifting effect known as cangiante.
The Healing of the Cripple and Raising of Tabitha, also on the upper right wall, combines two episodes from the Acts of the Apostles in a single urban setting. Peter and John heal a cripple before a perspectival loggia, while Peter raises Tabitha beside a house. The central view resembles fifteenth-century Florence, with a perspective square, crenellated houses, objects hanging between windows, richly dressed townspeople, and passers-by. The composition is generally attributed to Masolino, although Masaccio’s participation has also been proposed.
Lost lunettes and upper decoration
The lost left lunette contained Masolino’s Calling of Saints Peter and Andrew, also called Peter’s Calling. It was divided into expanses of sea and sky, and a later drawing identified by Roberto Longhi is considered a probable record of its composition. The opposite lunette contained the Navicella, in which Christ walks on water and rescues Peter from a storm. Its marine setting balanced the other lunette and formed a sequence from the Evangelists in the vault, through the sea of the upper register, to the land and cities below.
The lost left semi-lunette contained Masaccio’s Repentance of Saint Peter, known through an incisive preparatory drawing discovered during restoration. The right semi-lunette contained Saint Peter’s Mission, also called Feed My Sheep. Four painted sheep helped identify its preparatory drawing in 1984. The scene shows Christ entrusting Peter with the role of universal shepherd and is generally attributed to Masolino. The original vault contained Masolino’s four Evangelists, but the paintings were destroyed when the vault was altered.
Lower register
The Raising of the Son of Theophilus
The large lower-left scene, The Raising of the Son of Theophilus and Saint Peter Enthroned, was begun by Masaccio in 1427 and completed about fifty years later by Filippino Lippi. Masaccio painted most of the central scene and the enthroned Saint Peter. Filippino added the five Florentine figures at the left, the resurrected boy and child, and several central figures and heads.
Painted architecture with marble panels frames the composition, with trees and vases visible behind it. The arrangement influenced later Florentine painters. Large losses, including the lower part of Saint Peter Enthroned, were integrated during the latest restoration. Numerous figures have been proposed as portraits of contemporaries, including Filippo Brunelleschi, Leon Battista Alberti, Masaccio, Masolino, Felice Brancacci, Filippo Lippi, Francesco Granacci, Cardinal Branda Castiglione, Gian Galeazzo Visconti, Coluccio Salutati, Cosimo de’ Medici, and Luigi Pulci. These identifications remain interpretive proposals.
Saint Peter Healing the Sick with His Shadow
Masaccio painted Saint Peter Healing the Sick with His Shadow on the lower left or centre wall. Peter and John walk through a street while Peter’s shadow heals several sick people. Two stand to thank him, one rises, and another remains crouched with deformed legs. The street leads perspectivally towards a church with a Corinthian column and bell tower, and the architecture continues into the window embrasure through an optical device.
The street has been tentatively identified with the Borgo degli Albizzi and the destroyed church of San Pier Maggiore, although that location remains hypothetical. Proposed portraits include Masolino, Masaccio’s brother Lo Scheggia as Saint John, Donatello, and other unidentified contemporaries.
The Distribution of Alms and Death of Ananias
On the lower right or centre wall, Masaccio painted The Distribution of Alms and Death of Ananias. It depicts the early Christian sharing of possessions and Ananias’s punishment after he withholds part of his property while declaring a false income. Buildings frame the tightly organized composition, whose vigorous figures and articulated architectural volumes give the scene a strong sense of physical structure.
Filippino Lippi’s completion
The lower-right panel, The Disputation with Simon Magus and the Crucifixion of Saint Peter, is entirely by Filippino Lippi. The scene takes place outside Rome, represented by the Pyramid of Cestius and the Aurelian Walls. Simon Magus and Peter dispute before Nero beside a toppled pagan idol, and Peter is crucified upside down because he refused to die in Christ’s manner. Proposed portraits include Filippino, Antonio del Pollaiuolo, and Sandro Botticelli. Simon Magus has sometimes been interpreted as Dante Alighieri, but this remains an attributional interpretation.
On the lower register of the left pilaster, Filippino painted Saint Peter Visited in Prison by Saint Paul. Peter looks through a barred window while Paul turns away from the viewer. Its architecture continues that of the adjoining Raising of the Son of Theophilus, and the composition may have followed a design by Masaccio. On the lower right wall, Filippino painted The Liberation of Saint Peter from Prison. An angel frees Peter while a sword-bearing guard sleeps in the foreground, leaning on a long staff. The architecture continues that of the adjoining scene. The painting was interpreted as an image of Christian salvation and possibly as an allusion to Florence’s recovery of autonomy after the Milanese threat.
Altar and surviving evidence
The altar relief of the Delivery of the Keys, attributed to Donatello and now in the Victoria and Albert Museum, probably completed the Saint Peter cycle. Its subject reinforced the theme of Peter’s authority in the Church. The Madonna del Popolo, a thirteenth-century Madonna and Child probably dating from around 1268, remains associated with the altar. Its attribution has shifted from Coppo di Marcovaldo or the Master of Sant’Agata to the more cautious designation Master of the Madonna del Carmine.
The lost Crucifixion of Saint Peter was intended for the rear wall beneath the former, smaller and higher window. It was probably painted by Masaccio and would have formed the visual and perspectival focus of the cycle. Peter was to be shown crucified upside down, with the vanishing point probably behind his face. Only two fragments at the sides and a painted fragment beneath the window were found. The scene was probably destroyed between 1435 and 1458 to make room for the Madonna del Popolo.
The restoration distinguished Masaccio’s, Masolino’s, and Filippino Lippi’s contributions while recovering decorative fragments, facial details, and evidence for paintings that no longer survive. Together, the remaining frescoes and these recovered traces preserve the chapel’s layered history, from its Brancacci foundation and fifteenth-century commission to its later alterations and conservation.
Nearby sites
