The Knights Templar after 1312: The Fate of Members and Property

When Pope Clement V suppressed the Knights Templar in 1312, the order’s corporate existence ended, but the fate of its members and property remained unsettled. Across Europe, the pope sought to redirect Templar lands and income to the Hospitallers. In Iberia, negotiations with rulers produced different arrangements, including the Portuguese Order of Christ and the Aragonese Order of Montesa. These transfers created new owners and institutions; they did not mean that the Templar order continued unchanged.

On this page5 sections

What happened to surviving Templars

Arrests and investigations had begun in 1307, but the suppression of the order was not a verdict that every Templar was guilty. At the Council of Vienne, Clement V dissolved the institution through the papal bull Vox in excelso, dated 22 March 1312. A papal bull is a formal decree issued by the pope. The suppression ended the order’s legal existence, while separate decisions addressed individual members.

In Considerantes dudum, issued on 6 May 1312, Clement set out different provisions for the former brothers. Men found innocent, or reconciled with the Church after confessing, could receive a pension and live in a religious house. Those who withdrew earlier confessions or were treated as relapsed heretics faced severe punishment. The fate of the order’s leaders was handled separately: Jacques de Molay and Geoffroi de Charney, who retracted their confessions, were burned in Paris on 18 March 1314.

For other former members, outcomes depended on the proceedings and authorities in their region. Some received pensions or permission to live in religious houses; others faced trials or punishment. In the Crown of Aragon, an inquiry pronounced the Templars innocent, yet the papal suppression still applied. Portugal’s King Denis protected Templars and resisted their persecution, but this protection did not preserve the order as a legal institution.

The papal transfer of Templar property

The bull Ad providam, issued on 2 May 1312, assigned most Templar property to the Hospitallers, members of the Order of St John of Jerusalem. Clement’s stated rationale was that wealth originally given to support the Church and the recovery of the Holy Land should remain available for those purposes. The grant covered more than land: it included Templar houses, churches, castles, farms, settlements, income, rights, privileges, and movable goods.

The decree established who should receive the property, but it did not make every transfer immediate. During the arrests, estates had been placed under the control of rulers or other authorities. After the papal decision, local claims and resistance could still obstruct the Hospitallers’ possession. In England, for example, the Crown, noble families, and people claiming through the original donors contested some estates. In 1338, more than a quarter-century after the decree, not all the former Templar property there had reached Hospitaller hands.

Why Iberian property followed different paths

Ad providam reserved the disposition of Templar property in Castile, Aragon, Portugal, and Mallorca rather than including it in the general grant to the Hospitallers. The region’s rulers had military and political reasons to seek control over the estates. Templar holdings included fortresses and other resources useful for frontier defence. Kings also had an interest in preventing a powerful military order with independent obligations to the papacy from gaining control of strategically important lands.

The reservation led to different results, not a single Iberian settlement. In Castile, King Ferdinand IV took control of former Templar lands. The Hospitallers and the papacy objected, and a papal complaint in 1366 indicates that Castile had still not met its obligations to the Hospitaller order. Elsewhere, prolonged negotiations produced new arrangements for Portugal and the Crown of Aragon.

Portugal and the Order of Christ

King Denis of Portugal resisted the transfer of Portuguese Templar estates to the Hospitallers and protected the former Templars from the kind of persecution seen in France. Rather than simply restore the dissolved order, he negotiated permission to establish a new military religious order. On 14 March 1319, Pope John XXII authorized the Order of Christ through the bull Ad ea ex quibus and assigned it the Portuguese Templar properties.

The settlement linked the new order to the Portuguese monarchy while retaining papal authorization. Its grand master was required to swear an oath to the king. The order first established its headquarters at Castro Marim and later moved to Tomar, a former Templar centre. Some former Templars may have joined it, but the establishment of a new body and the transfer of property are clearer than the extent of any transfer of membership. The Order of Christ was a successor in particular assets and military functions, not simply the Templar order under a new name.

The Crown of Aragon and the Order of Montesa

James II of Aragon also sought to prevent the Hospitallers from acquiring all the region’s former Templar holdings. In the settlement approved by John XXII in 1317, the Hospitallers received Templar property in Aragon and Catalonia. In Valencia, however, the estates of both the Templars and the Hospitallers were assigned to a new order, Santa Maria of Montesa. The arrangement was formally put into effect in 1319.

Montesa was based at Montesa Castle and followed the Cistercian rule, a monastic framework governing religious life. It was created to defend the frontier and serve the military needs of the kingdom. Giving Valencia’s estates to this regional order allowed James to retain a closer connection to their management than a general transfer to the Hospitallers would have done. Montesa had its own leadership and religious rule, and links to other Iberian military orders. It was a new institution formed through the settlement of property, rather than an uninterrupted continuation of the Templars.

After 1312, therefore, the fates of former members and former estates did not follow the same path. Some brothers received pensions or other individual settlements, while most Templar property was assigned to the Hospitallers, subject to local resistance and Iberian exceptions. Portugal and Valencia acquired distinct new orders through papal and royal negotiations. The movement of people or property between institutions did not, by itself, preserve the Templar order’s identity.